My husband and I just had the conversation where he got to tell me "I told you so".
By my very nature I am a sceptical person. So when I started using twitter, I took it slowly. I followed people I knew, knew of or I was interested in. And it wasn’t long until I was on my way.
Phil was dubious. “What are you doing, meeting dudes on there?” And I guess, if he starting talking or tweeting to random people on the internet, I too would be a bit put out. But it has never been about that. Not for me anyway. I talk to lots of people about lots of things. And I’d like to think I’ve made some very strong and real connections since mid last year when I started “social networking”. I’m not in it for the networking side, just the social bit. Oh and the fact I am a bit of a news junkie, I find that the news travels to Twitter way quicker than TV or radio a lot of the time.
I’m not looking for new best friends. I’ve already got mine and they could never be replaced.
It’s kind of hard to know though, when people are just showing you a facade on the net. I mean, there are endless avenues to secure fake photos, personas and lives and basically turn themselves into anybody they would like to be.
A year ago, I didn’t even really know what a blog was. I was introduced by an acquaintance. She told me I should check out hers and gave me the web address. The first thing I noted was that it was kind of like an online journal of her life. I was intrigued. So much of her life was on there. I mean I knew her, she was also my neighbour and whilst I wouldn't say we hung out, I knew a fair bit about her. Her blog displayed lots of crafty things she made. She is very talented and absolutely gifted at holding kids parties. But then again, if I did nothing all day, I reckon I could whip up a pretty outstanding Lego Man party myself. It wasn’t long until she started to rant. About stuff that I could see she was clearly being hypocritical about. She made out she was the worlds biggest earth mother and dutiful wife, whilst in reality, she was good at keeping her husband firmly planted under her thumb and borrowing tools and gear off her neighbours and then hastily turning around and talking smack about them. At one point, she called her husband home from work one day to clean her sons arse. True story.
In short, her on-line and real life personas, just did not match up. It was easy to make herself into something she wasn't. What struck me though was that in the end, she was only deluding herself.
So, having said that do I change my mind on subjects? Yes. Do I say stuff in one breath and then maybe contradict myself in the next? I don’t intend to but maybe I do? When you are trying to entertain and be funny, sometimes situations are made to look more entertaining than they actually were. Let’s face it, me saying I stood in line with a tantrumming toddler whilst someone took too long at the ATM is not as funny as the way I blog about it. But all in all, I’ve stayed true to who I am and what our family represent which is basically organised chaos.
For instance I could not have made up the last year I have been through. I just couldn’t have. Cancer, broken bones, surgery, breast cancer scares, teeth pulled, tampon painting. Could I put all of that out there just for the fun of it? Well I couldn’t. You have to have a good memory to make it as a good lier. And my mind is like a freaking sieve.
OK, so what this really is about is my last 48 hours.
During that time, it has come to light, someone I follow on Twitter, someone I have actually met in real life (only 1 of 2 I have actually done this with) turned out to be a total scammer and a fraud.
She led me, and a lot of other people to believe a lot of things that are simply just not true. Basically, she sucked a lot of people into believing she was incredibly sick with cancer. She made up fake people online that she used to con money from unsuspecting, good hearted people.
I should have followed my gut instinct. That something was off. That and the fact that she was incredibly rude to the majority of the retail assistants she spoke with that day. But hey, she was meant to have cancer. You can't call bullshit on someone with cancer over a "gut feeling".
Where the lies start and end, at this point in time, are undefinable. It was elaborate. It was started at least over a year ago and a lot of good, smart and trusting people were sucked in. The sad thing is, at the end of the day, if she really was sick, we all would have embraced her. Probably even helped her out financially eventually should she have needed it. But now, well now, she’s fucked herself. And she’s tarnished a lot of what I thought was cool about this whole “community”, which is really sad, because I reckon 99% of the people I know, follow and speak with, are really fun, smart, and genuine people.
I think this may very well be, the modern day scam. And I think I’ve had my very first taste of the evil side of the net.



48 comments:
That's exactly how I feel too Bern. My first bad encounter. One bad seed out of how many? 150 odd. Guess that's probably the same odds with meeting people in Real Life?
Hugs to you Bern. Don't let it change the person that you are. xx
What can I say? You've said it all.
It's fucked, and you know I NEVER swear online.
Oh except when she asked us all to say 'Fuck cancer' on her blog. Yeah...f you is what we should have said. :(
ouch - yeah, i've run into the supposedly homeless, begging for help - only to find the reason they aren't being helped by the government is because they refuse to look for work, because they think they're not bound by the same rules as the rest of us.
I'm sorry you got had - we all do.
Don't let her deter you there are still other true people out there like us that you tweet with..she just was a clown short of a circus I guess!!
Firstly, I have never heard (or read?) the work 'fuck' come out of Thea's mouth (or keyboard?).
Secondly, it is fucked. It's a shame that one person had to ruin the party for the rest of us. That being said, I hope we don't dwell on this for too long. She obviously isn't worth thinking about. And this doesn't change the fact that I really do want to meet all my genuine Twitter friends one day.
A kick to the neck? What that woman needs is a kick to the head.
99% is probably not true Bern. There are probably only 45- 50% of people out there who are true and honest. The unfortunate thing about SNS phenomena is that it has given scammers a new avenue to rip you off. The doorstep sob stories don't work anymore, the spam emails don't work any more. But through blogs and Twitter and interaction we come to care about people. That is the root of the nasty cons in history - using our sense of altruism against us. Once the innocence has gone we have less time for the really needy people. Report this person to the ACCC and ACMA by the way. They effing deserve it.
I'm with Jane - I'd love to meet my twitter friends one day. I truly believe that while absolutely horrible and well and truly fucked, what she has done goes so far and beyond simply lying - you are just all super unlucky to have had it affect you.
I am a strong believer in karma. This is going to come back and bite her, hard. I'm just sorry that she has hurt you all so much, because she never deserved friends as lovely as you all seem to be.
This is such a great post with a great title. That is ridiculous and sad, what she did. Having genuinely been very ill, the last thing I'd ever, ever want is attention for it that wasn't purely to help raise awareness. Sicko, seriously.
In other news, I pride myself on being as myself as I can on my blog. That's not me trying to plug my blog, it's just that I hate the idea that I'd portray myself as something I'm not - I could never deliberately do it.
Great post x
I hear these stories about scammers on the net and I feel all smug and sanctimonious that I would never fall for such rubbish. It seems so far fetched and so unreasonable. I mean who would believe that some Nigerian woman wants to marry me? I mean after all I am a Jewish girl living in Sydney....but J was no different.
I fell for her elaborate ruse hook, line and sinker. I cried for her. I wanted to give her hope AND MONEY because hey she needed $30 000 to save her life. I fell for that!! I am horrified with myself. And ashamed. And burned.
But I truly still feel sad for J. She is sick. VERY sick. She is mentally disturbed and now she has NO ONE. Not a soul. She had people who cared about her. Who would have cared about her even if she did not have cancer. She was funny and smart and entertaining. We liked her for her, not because we felt pity for her. And now no one likes her. And she must really hate herself.
I agree missea, she's clocked up a lot of karma for what she's done & when it comes to get her, she's going to feel the sting for sure! Sorry you got up close & personal with her Bern, makes having to swallow the episode far more bitter! Lollipopins
Sorry to hear this, it is very unpleasant to be taken in this way. The same thing happened me in a real life situation, someone lying through their teeth and I felt sick over it and was raging with myself for falling for it, but it was a friend and I believed her.
I am on twitter, must try find you there. I am still a bit twitter shy but do enjoy the quick banter:)
Hope you are ok.
Jen
Hi Bern, I feel for all of you who have been affected by this. I am not such a strong twitter user but I do remember reading on twitter when the coma thing happened and being very moved and touched by the support that was given, essentially to a stranger. How awful that such genuine care and concern has been stolen by someone so dishonest. What an elaborate scam! No-one could blame anyone for being duped..I mean who would think anyone would go to so much effort?
I have chosen not to put identifying info about myself on twitter, but I am a real person and other than not knowing my full name I am the person I portray on twitter. I have real life friends I talk to on twitter as well as lots of "acquaintances" who keep me up to date and entertained.
I hope the word is spread about this to make everyone aware of just what lengths these people will go to.
Cheers
Sue (Just_Leithal)
I lost your blog! its endlessly funny but ultimately honest. it always makes me smile and feel im not some freak alone in the world.
I havent been scammed but ive been stalked, as in proper stalked, my stalker followed my hubby to work harassed him there, my daycare too, facestalked and forum stalked, when my hubby died she turned up to the funeral, uninvited .. It was then i took a stand. All this hasnt turned me off the net, blogging or meeting people, its just made me trust my guy instinct more. I trust my bullshit sensors inside me.
i feel sad for people who have to make that kind of stuff up, they truley need help. i feel genuine pity for them.
i love that you use fuck as much as i do LOL
love danielle
I have a hard time feeling bad for people who prey on the good intentions of others.
This person needs help. She is sick indeed. I just hope that she can get it for herself because it seems as though she has burned all her bridges.
Jesus! That is just sick! I don't really "know" nor follow her on Twitter but that is just sad and sick at the same time.
And FTR, I am not a figment of your imagination.=)
Great post Bern. One thing I'm sure of is that this isn't going to harden me to others who might be real and in need. Perhaps make me just a little more cautious.
Cheering for honesty.
Why bother making yourself out to something you aren't online - why do it?? self centered self absorbed self obsessed - that people might like a fictional character more than the real person?
I'm all for raw truth - even if you do contradict yourself at times.
I was burned with a similar scam last year and learned a valuable lesson from it. I always kept my distance for that reason. Trust your instincts. But the thing to remember is YOU did the right thing. And so did alot of other people on twitter. And that makes me proud to call you my friends. Because of her lies, what does she have?
This is fucked because we liked her and we would have gone to any lengths to help her. I, too, was trying to come up with ideas about how to get her the #30,000 for her "life-saving surgery".
It makes me sick thinking about how she must have been laughing at us over our concern for her and thinking how smart she was.
I've been conned before and swore I'd never let it happen again. I listened to my intuition. Whilst I was devising ways to raise money for her, I didn't send her any. Something told me not to and over the past couple of weeks, as she was meeting people from Twitter and FB and pics were being posted, red flags started waving.
I will say this...she's not as smart as she thought and the thing that led to her undoing was the one thing she wanted most...FRIENDS, real friends.
As usual, I have no freaking idea what is going on.
Sounds real sucky, though.
Wow, who are we talking about? I musta missed the whole situation.
I met someone at a market the other day - she facebooked me and I then had friend who picked up the connection on facebook call me to ask WTF and warn me to be very careful as she was essentially a conwoman who had burned many. I just thought she was a nice person who it turned out moved in circles I knew.
You wouldn't read about it. Except you just did. And whilst I wasn't burned, goes to show just how easily it can happen in real life too.
I am super skeptical of the net and yet I think it's a great connector and a very dynamic way of communicating with people you may miss out in life otherwise. I found you as an example :). But I'd be wary of anyone that is super keen/too much...there should be a life outside of the net for it to feel as healthy as I'd like it to.
And just for the record, I am absolutely as wonderful as I seem :)
xx
Awesome post Bern. I was reading a book for my ecommerce degree that the act of creating an online persona is a real illness. There are some bizarre cases out there.
I have nothing new to add... I feel like a prize idiot. BUT, will this stop me being a trusting person? Will it stop me wanting to help people? Hell no. She will not take that from me.
I have something else to say...I AM who I have said I am. I'm neither a liar, nor a conwoman. Things like this don't make me stop trusting people, it does, however make me realize I HAVE TO go with my gut instinct. It's always right...well, 99% of the time.
N x
Great post- no wonder Mia Freedman is battering at your door trying to follow you...
You summarised this all beautifully. Ultimately, she is the one who loses. I know now to to be even more careful online, but overall I've still gained so much more from my online friends than I've lost or had called into question. So much!
Wow, scary. Not sure what is going on, but I think there is one key thing you said Bern: "I should have followed my gut instinct." I think we all can sense when someone is being honest and when something is "off". But we are afraid of appearing rude or thoughtless so we override those instincts.
I've not encountered this on the net as of yet. I have encountered bloggers that give me that "off" feeling and I just avoid their sites. You can't mistake raw honesty when you read it. It just shines through. Don't second guess yourself. Trust your instincts.
It's sad and it's scary. I hope this doesn't affect my online life but I'm sure I'll be pretty wary for a while.
Lying about having Cancer just to get stuff sucks balls.
And just because you do or don't have cancer doesn't give you the right to treat people like shit either.
Thanks for all the comments. Like Sharpest pencil said, she really was funny, smart and entertaining on her blogs. We all would have been her friend. But that's not what she's after I don't think.
Glad someone is finally coming out and writing exactly what has happened. I had a bit of a wtf is going on moment yesterday and everyone didn't want to name names or go into detail.
I can't believe I fell for her bullshit too. I don't understand how anyone caught her out as she was a professional liar as she had so many fooled. I started to think something was up when she asked for help (eg: money, a place to stay, help with things she needed) on Facebook from people she barely knew.
Glad I didn't meet her, sent her a birthday canvas like she asked of people or spent too much time talking to her. I'm a bit mistrusting of people on the net like that.
Please don't think of everyone on the net to be out there to scam or mislead you Bern :) most of us are just here for social activities too. Just for a chat and a laugh.
I am sad about this. I've talked about J to people. I enjoyed talking with her (well, tweeting). I've reflected on her 'experience' to remind myself how lucky I am.
And therein lies a point. It may have been fiction. And I'm incredibly sorry that a lot of people feel hurt and used. But (and here's my Pollyanna side), even though it was made up, that illness gave me a perspective I needed a couple of times.
The thing is someone, somewhere out there, IS going through this. Maybe we all need to find (metaphorically) that real person and try to make a difference - unasked - in their life.
So in a weird, VERY weird, kind of a way, J changed my life for the better.
i'm sorry you had this experience, Bern. i've kind of watched it from afar, followed the same person you did, but never got involved. no particular reason for that. just didn't. i've been on the net since 1995, using IRC and other realtime chat programs to do what we now call social networking. it was bruising and exhilerating and hurtful, and ultimately, i met my partner there (15 years in january). i suspect that everyone needs to be stung at some point to learn that the net is a beautiful but anarchic thing. good and bad thrive there equally. only time will tell you whether people are as their online personas suggest. i'm sorry that you got hurt, and i'm particularly sorry for those who got stung financially and emotionally by this woman. hopefully, everyone learns from the experience, though i suspect her lesson will go unlearned, given her no doubt parlous mental state.
Wow.
Am very gobsmacked by this and sad.
I have no idea who she is but it sounds as though there are heaps of people out there who have been hurt by her motives.
Gosh, that really sucks.
I met up with some tweeps I'd tweeted with in NZ, and luckily they were all nice and funny in real life as they were online.
Actually even nicer.
Silly, I always warn my kids about the internet and that you can't always believe people are who they say they are ... never really applied it to myself.
After your experience, I'll be a bit more careful, but I still love my online mates - like you - who I've never had the pleasure to meet in real life, but who make me smile/laugh/cry everyday.
Yeah, wow, like some of the others above I'm not au fait with this situation but it doesn't sound good. So sorry you've been let down like this, Bern - that always sucks.
Facebook is about connecting with people who you went to high school with. Twitter is about connecting with people you wish you went to high school with.
A Kick to the Neck was never in either of those lists (now I know it's not because I'm an unsympathetic arsehole, but because I have a high-tuned subconscious hyper-awareness defensive BS detector) but I'd checked out her blog, only recently followed her but mostly just heard about her from what I consider to be bona fide tweeps (one uses a cuss word above for perhaps the first time ever) so it was pretty crazy to see what had happened. I hadn't realised she was asking for $30K - odd.
I guess it just goes to show that showing sympathy and compassion is fine, but before you commit dollars, check the facts.
Again, comments all very much appreciated. I guess I should point out, I didn't give her any money. My heckles were up but that's not to say, had I seen others (like you say anidledad, bona fide tweeps) starting to give her money to get life saving surgery, I reckon I may have. Right now, all we can hope, is that she doesn't get the chance to do it again. The fraud squad aren't interested because really, the cash side was negligible.
I do like Apple gadgets though: Any chance, Bern? $5K? C'mon.
God at least come up with some kind of life threatening, yet rarely cured disease first!! lol
No idea who or what and most defniitely why. But don't let someone like that change the way you operate, Bern.
um wow, I'm very new to all this and was wondering what it was all about, not entirely sure finding out was a good thing. This is just all kinds of wrong and badness. Serious issues is the term that most springs to mind. Sucks balls hard that you all got hurt, your post was really bang on Bern.
xxpt
Like some others, I missed this whole experience, for which I admit to being grateful. So sorry that you, Bern, and so many other of my favourite tweeps were taken in by this woman's fabricated life.
Feeling a certain amount of disgust as an outsider - I watched my Dad died of cancer a decade ago, and to think that she took on all the subtext of physical and mental suffering that cancer sufferers and their families go through and wrapped it around herself to form this persona?...well, makes my stomach turn.
On the subject of trust and social media - I love the way all of you are responding, both in terms of mutual support, and in reiterating your trust in the majority of relationships you have built on the 'net. She IS the exception rather than the rule. Letting damaged people like her stop us from making and enjoying the beautiful, heartfelt, empathetic relationships we are discovering through Twitter and each others blogs..well, that would be the real tragedy.
Hugs all round, for all of you that have been touched by her poison - but revel in the way that it pulls the rest of the community together, and pity her in her loneliness. xxx
I'm stunned that this happened. Maybe that's a sign that I'm a little naive. It's very sad that people think it's ok to do this.
Goes to show how vulnerable our children are, if we as adults are so easily duped.
Gosh Bern, that sounds terrible. I don't understand what motivates people to do these sorts of things.
*hug*
Such a baffling story that I had to save this post to come and leave a comment (even if it's a little belated!)
I don't know the culprit, but pretending to have an illness is disgusting behaviour. As someone who does suffer a chronic illness and uses the net a lot for social interaction, I am outraged by the amount of fakes that end up making life harder for us, not just online but in the medical system also.
Someone up there (sorry, it's a long list ;P) commented that this person DOES have an illness, just not the one she claims to have and I have to agree! One would have to be sick to go around pretending to be ill, even to make money - living with a chronic condition and having to talk and think about it constantly is no picnic, I don't know why anyone would want to fake it other than that they are mentally disturbed!
Oh, that is so sick. I'd never lie about cancer...tempting the gods and all.
NO thanks..
Late to the party...that is heavy.
Post a Comment