Let’s just say I didn’t expect to like this movie. I had attempted to read the book. I tried, I really did, but I just couldn’t do it. To be honest, I didn’t give it a red hot go because it just didn’t appeal to me at the time. I’ve found the people who swear by Eat, Pray Love and would just about take a bullet for Liz Gilbert the author, have recently gone through a life struggle of some kind themselves. That doesn’t mean the non-fiction, best seller isn’t fantastic, it’s just that for me, I didn’t identify with it at the time.
And let’s face it, when reading something that mirrors our own experience, it’s fair to say, it’s a lot more interesting for the person doing the reading, than say something that doesn't. So when Elizabeth Gilbert penned her story, which in short, is about her being bored with life, uneasy with her marriage and over her seemingly fantastic career, she resonated with many people.
The movie, from what I understand, omits a lot of the book as often happens when a book gets adapted to screen. Because of this, some of the feelings, the apprehension and the crisis that is supposedly affecting Liz, played by Julia Roberts, aren’t all that obvious in the film.
The movie, like the book, centres around Elizabeth Gilbert, a writer who, again this is how the movie portrays her, seems to have a pretty sweet life traveling from exotic destination to exotic destination penning columns for a magazine. She also has “another book” coming out in the near future. Her professional life is going great. She’s married to an affable guy who hasn’t quite pinned down his chosen career and who is thinking of going back to University to study. Presumably on her dime. He longs for children. She doesn’t.
It’s about this time; Liz interviews an Indonesian medicine man in Bali who tells her 3 things.
She will have two marriages. One long. One short. She will lose all her money. But she will make it back again. And she will come back and visit him again. At this point I wondered if she kind of made the prophecy come true. Like when you see a psychic and she tells you will sell your house, even though it’s the furtherest thing from your mind. Suddenly, something unexpected happens, you see a "sign" and it's time to sell the house. Did he just plant the seed and she watered the garden?
So Liz chucks it all in. Essentially she runs away from her husband, breaks his heart, hooks up with a guy very much her junior within a relatively short period of time and lives with him. That too, although poorly represented in the movie, goes to hell in a hand basket with Liz finding it is not working. She is not happy and she needs to “find herself”.
At total odds with her situation, she plans a year that takes in Italy, where she eats, India, where she prays and Bali, where she finds love. The fact that Liz meets a collective bunch of friends and acquaintances along the way, certainly helps her journey of self-discovery. I wonder what her outcome would have been, had she not met the people she did. Very different I Imagine. Loneliness makes your heart break a little more.
So, did it work? Yeah, it was watchable. The scenery was glorious and made me, a fairly unseasoned traveler; want to investigate the chances of one day seeing some of these beautiful spots, especially Rome. Did it make me want to chuck in my day job, nick off to Italy to feed my face until I burst my jean buttons? No. It made me appreciate that I am happy with my everyday life. But she wasn’t happy with that, and that’s why she did what she did. And no one should judge another when it comes to one’s own personal happiness.
Julia Roberts is well, Julia Roberts. She could lie down in cow dung and make pig noises and she’d still have loyal followers and people to love her. For me, it was all I could see. Julia Roberts. A different actor would have made this movie so different in my honest opinion.
So should you drop a twenty and go see it? Yes and no. If you want a night out with the girls where you get all philosophical on yourselves after wards - YES. If you really don’t have the twenty to waste - NO. Oh, but the soundtrack – a definite YES.
There are over 403 Liz Gilbert Quotes. That’s a lot of self help. For my money, I still think all you need in life is the Sunscreen Song:
|



18 comments:
Wowzer. Bugger EPL- I have never heard the Sunscreen Song and I love it! That's my sort of mantra. :)
It may be missing one line though... "Life is too short not to eat Lindt."
hmm, sounds suspiciously like the kind of crap my wife would watch - you have to love Julia though :-)
Very thoughtful. When I read book, I had hard time at first identifying w/ Liz and thought she was a whiner. She was rich, successful & having Identity crisis. WAAAAAH! Someone call a Wammmbulance! Hard to identify w/ someone who had so much success in other aspects of their lives and feel sorry for them. She just seemed irresponsible in her relationships w/ other's feelings. Of course her first husband did what any scorned spouse would do... hit her in the pocketbook. He cleaned her out. Think she became more thoughtful of others as the book evolved. Wound up liking her despite initial reaction.
I loved the book! Loved it!!
But I've heard so much negative feedback about the movie I won't be paying to see it.
Julia was just not what I imagined as I was reading, she's not right. Liz was 30 for starters, Julia is...not.
I might wait until it comes to free to air. :)
I couldn't read the book - I think, like you, I was not in the right place. But I'm not sure I'll ever be in that place. For this reason, I will save my movie dollars for The Ghost Writer or some such.
Hello, Hello,
I read the book and I'm off to see the movie today. I can't wait to see what the fuss is about. I loved the Eat part of the book, wasn't too thrilled with Pray and then enjoyed Love. I am a JR fan and I've heard the scenery is cool...so my guess is that I'll happily immerse myself in EG's journey for a couple of hours. Will let you know what I think.
Pink Fibro girl: Do yourself a favour and see The Ghost Writer. It is brilliant. I promise I am biased though am totally in love with Ewan M.
Sorry, I meant to say I am NOT biased!
Loved the book, loved the movie. It is amazing how divisive both have been. But for me, it's one woman's story, and she tells it with such class in the book. I only wish I'd written it first...! ;)
i brought this movie home from Bali, put it on for 15 mins and turned it of, i didnt like it at all. and i love julia roberts.. i may read the book instead, hopefully it wont bore me to death.
I love Julia Roberts and I suspect that she made Liz Gilbert so much more likeable that she really is. But agree 100% about the movie. I didn't relate at all and found myself a bit smug about finding myself much earlier than mid 30s. But can understand many an unsatisfied woman LOVING this story. That being said, I didn't mind the movie and it was great fodder for our girls night out :-) Thanks for your review. Very good!
In the book, I loved Eat (the best) and Pray, but the Love section was awful. I found her new guy sleazy and aimless. Not sure about the movie. I'll probably see it on Fox!
As for the Sunscreen Song - totally with you on that. I haven't seen it written down before but completely related to it when it was on the radio. Thanks for the reminder!
I have not read the book, and will probably not see the movie. I am the first to admit I have no basis for this next statement... but just the idea of the book makes me stabby. Not the reaction the author intended. I love my yoga, I love my Buddhist meditation classes... I love the idea of travel, but something about the way she goes about it seems very self indulgent and the opposite to what she seeks.It seems hypocritical. But like I said, I have no basis for this. I saw her interviewed on Oprah, and was left cold. That's all I have to go on.
As for the sunscreen song... truer word were never spoken.
Love Julia Roberts....might go and check this one out......
Haven't read the book or seen the movie. The book did interest me for a while until I found out that the author had done the travelling on a publisher's advance. That just seemed a bit too contrived for me, and then when Oprah picked it up .... pass. My To Be Read pile is already high enough, thanks.
A much better book in the Woman Travelling Alone Trying to Find Herself genre is Alice Steinbach's 'Without Reservations'. Written about 10 years ago.
I want to see the movie. I read the book, and as you probably know, really enjoyed it. It surprised me that I liked it, because I had resisted it so long after seeing Elizabeth on Oprah, and Oprah gushing over her book (which I found off-putting). But I liked it. Even the India section where most people switch off. I like to think she decided to try and keep the positive when writing it, because no one's life is that lucky or perfect as it sounds in the book. ;)
Great post, Bern!
I've had three goes at reading the book, and I just get so annoyed at EG I want to slap her. I just couldn't get past her whining. The ads for the movie don't make me want to see it either. I don't want to spend a couple of hours watching JR eating with her mouth full and being likeable. But then I am a cranky cow going through my own midlife crisis and with no money or freedom to travel around the world 'finding' myself.
Ugh! I read the book and I just wanted to slap her. The "poor little rich girl gets screwed in her divorce" line just doesn't work with me. There are far more devastating things to happen in one's life than being a squillionaire and getting taken to the cleaners and then being sent travelling round the world on your publisher's credit card. I as so looking forward to reading this, but now I would like my $25 back please.
Post a Comment